Personal Lines Sales and Service Representative

Join Our Team at Keystone Insurance Brokers (A Leavitt Group Affiliate)

Are you a motivated sales professional who loves building relationships but has struggled to find enough quality leads in past roles? At Keystone Insurance Brokers, we’ve solved that problem for you.

We are a well-established and growing agency backed by the Leavitt Group—one of the nation’s largest privately held insurance brokerages. With our cutting-edge marketing strategies, you’ll enjoy a steady flow of warm inbound leads from clients already seeking coverage. No cold calling, no chasing—just the chance to do what you do best: help people and close deals.

The Opportunity

As a Personal Lines Insurance Sales & Service Representative, you’ll step into a role where success comes from your ability to connect, consult, and guide clients to the right coverage—not from pounding the phones looking for prospects.

This is your chance to combine sales expertise with relationship-building skills in an environment designed for growth and high earning potential. This position is available in either agency location in Valencia or New Castle.

What You’ll Do

• Be the first point of contact for inbound calls and online inquiries from people actively shopping for insurance.

• Listen to client needs and recommend tailored coverage solutions that give them peace of mind.

• Present and explain policies in a way that’s clear, confident, and client-focused.

• Provide quotes, process applications, and support clients with renewals and policy changes.

• Stay sharp on personal lines insurance products, trends, and requirements so you’re always adding value.

• Follow up with clients and referrals to boost retention and sales opportunities.

• Partner with carriers and underwriters to ensure smooth policy issuance.

• Deliver the kind of service that turns first-time clients into long-term relationships.

What We’re Looking For

• Proven experience in insurance sales (personal lines preferred: auto, home, renters, etc.).

• Active Property & Casualty (P&C) license in Pennsylvania.

• Strong communication, negotiation, and people skills.

• A results-driven mindset with the motivation to succeed.

• Comfort working both independently and as part of a team.

• Experience with CRM software and Microsoft Office, knowledge of AMS360 a plus.

Why You’ll Love Working Here

• No Cold Calling – we provide the leads so you can focus on selling.

• Competitive pay structure – base salary + uncapped commission (your success determines your earning potential).

• Comprehensive benefits – health, dental, vision, 401(k) with match.

• Work-life balance – paid time off and holidays.

• Growth opportunities – ongoing training, professional development, and career advancement.

• Be part of a national network – The Leavitt Group has 275+ locations across 27 states, giving you resources, markets, and career paths you won’t find elsewhere.

Ready to Take the Next Step?

If you’re ready to turn inbound leads into lasting client relationships while building a rewarding career, we’d love to hear from you.

Apply today and grow with Keystone Insurance Brokers and the Leavitt Group.

As a national company, the Leavitt Group is one of the largest privately-held insurance agency brokerage in the nation, with over 275 locations across 27 states. We broker commercial and personal lines insurance which manages the risk for individuals and businesses. The agency is appointed with the top insurance markets and enjoys exclusive representation with multiple insurance companies. We are always looking for talented individuals who want to further their career and grow with us.

#LI-EM1

#LI-Onsite